Trademark Dispute: Monster Energy Wins Interim Injunction Against Shree Parvati Fitness Hub

The Delhi Commercial Court issued a significant ruling in favour of Monster Energy Company in its ongoing trademark infringement case against Shree Parvati Fitness Hub Private Limited. The court granted an interim injunction, restraining the defendants from using the "Monster" trademark and related branding for food and protein supplements.

 

Case Background: Monster Energy, a globally recognized beverage company, filed a suit against Shree Parvati Fitness Hub, alleging that their use of trademarks like "Monster Series" and "Monster Energy Fuel" for nutritional supplements infringed upon Monster Energy's registered trademarks and distinctive trade dress. The company cited its long-standing international presence and trademark registrations dating back to 2006 in India.

 

 

Trademark Infringement: The court recognized Monster Energy as the prior adopter and registered proprietor of the "Monster" mark, emphasizing that the defendants' use of similar names and green-black packaging could cause consumer confusion.

 

Territorial Jurisdiction: Despite the defendants' claim that the case should be tried in Maharashtra, the court ruled that their products' online availability in Delhi justified the jurisdiction.

 

Goodwill and Reputation: The court noted the global reputation and distinctiveness of Monster Energy's branding, particularly the claw-like "M" icon and green-on-black design, which have been associated with the company since 2002.

 

Defence Claims Rejected: The defendants argued that the word "Monster" is common and generic, inspired by the fictional character "Hulk." They also claimed no similarity, citing different product classes (beverages vs. supplements). However, the court dismissed these arguments, stressing that product classification does not negate the risk of confusion among consumers.

 

 

Immediate Cessation: The defendants must stop manufacturing and marketing products using the disputed marks.

 

Inventory Clearance: Existing stock may be sold until December 31, 2024, provided detailed records are submitted.

 

Online Platforms: E-commerce sites must remove infringing listings.

 

Implications: This decision reinforces the importance of trademark protection and highlights the growing scrutiny of intellectual property enforcement in India's expanding e-commerce sector.